Pittsburgh Public Schools Board faces backlash amid proposed school closures
Share
Updated: 7:24 AM EDT Mar 25, 2025
Video Player is loading.
Current Time 0:00
/
Duration 0:00
Loaded: 0%
Stream Type LIVE
Remaining Time -0:00
1x
Chapters
descriptions off, selected
captions settings, opens captions settings dialog
captions off, selected
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
End of dialog window.
✕
I’M KRISTEN POWERS. I’M ANDREW STOCKEY IN FOR MIKE CLARK. PITTSBURGH PUBLIC SCHOOLS CONSIDERING CLOSING OVER A DOZEN SCHOOLS. IT’S AN ISSUE THAT HAS STRUCK A MAJOR CHORD IN THE COMMUNITY. REPORTER FELICITY TAYLOR WAS AT THAT MEETING AND JOINS US LIVE NOW. FELICITY, A HUGE TURNOUT TONIGHT. YEAH. THAT’S RIGHT. THE MEETING ACTUALLY JUST ENDED ONLY ABOUT 15 MINUTES AGO. AND WHEN IT WAS STARTING AT 6:00, THERE WAS A LINE OUT THE DOOR HERE TO GET IN TO GIVE SOME PUBLIC COMMENT. ALMOST 130 PEOPLE SIGNING UP TO SPEAK. AND THEY HAD A RESOUNDING MESSAGE FOR THE SCHOOL BOARD. SLOW DOWN AND DO NOT VOTE TO START THAT PROCESS YET. WHY ARE WE RUSHING INTO A VOTE THAT COULD HAVE SUCH DEVASTATING CONSEQUENCES FOR THE CITY? PARENTS, STUDENTS AND TEACHERS PACKING THE PITTSBURGH SCHOOL BOARD PUBLIC HEARING MONDAY, TRYING TO GET AHEAD OF WEDNESDAY’S SCHOOL BOARD MEETING, WHERE THE BOARD WILL VOTE ON WHETHER TO BEGIN THE PROCESS OF HAVING PUBLIC HEARINGS ON POTENTIALLY CLOSING 14 SCHOOLS, INCLUDING TEN SCHOOL BUILDINGS. THE YEAR’S PLAN IS LACKING IN DATA, PARTICULARLY WHEN IT COMES TO DEMOGRAPHICS, TRANSPORTATION COSTS AND CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS, PLANS AND LONG TERM COSTS. CONSIDERING THE CREATION OF THIS PLAN WAS DRIVEN BY CONCERNS ABOUT OUR BUDGET DEFICITS, YOU’D THINK WE’D BE LOOKING AT SOME FINANCIAL ESTIMATES. ERS, THE CONSULTING GROUP THAT DID THE FEASIBILITY STUDY, TOLD PPS TO HIRE A DEMOGRAPHER, WHICH HAS NOT BEEN DONE YET. THE MAJORITY OF FAMILIES REPRESENTED WERE FROM CONROY, THE STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT CENTER AND WOLFSLAIR. THOSE ARE THREE OF THOSE PROPOSED CLOSURES IN THE PLAN. WHILE MOST SPEAKERS WERE AGAINST CLOSING THE SCHOOLS ALTOGETHER, A SMALL GROUP SAYS THEY UNDERSTAND IT’S NECESSARY. I ALSO BELIEVE IT’S IMPORTANT FOR THE DISTRICT TO BEGIN CLOSING SOME OF THE FACILITIES THAT ARE NO LONGER NEEDED BECAUSE OF DECLINING ENROLLMENT AND THE AGING POPULATION. IT’S NEVER GOING TO BE EASY TO CHOOSE TO CLOSE SCHOOLS. I BELIEVE IT’S YOUR JOB TO FIGURE OUT WHAT TO DO, WHETHER IT’S THE ORIGINAL ERS PLAN, THE UPDATED PLAN THAT WAS ROLLED OUT, OR EVEN THE PARENT PROPOSAL. SCHOOL BOARD PRESIDENT GENE WALKER, ALSO ADDRESSING THE CROWD. THE WORK THAT WE’VE BEEN DOING UP TO THIS POINT, A LOT OF IT IS REALLY HARD, AND IT CERTAINLY IS NOT AND HAS NOT BEEN PERFECT. WE AND I SHARE MANY OF THE SAME CONCERNS THAT THAT MANY HAVE EXPRESSED, AND SOME WILL EXPRESS TONIGHT, BUT I BELIEVE THIS BOARD IS COMMITTED TO ENSURING THAT ALL INFORMATION IS PROVIDED. NO. TAKE THAT VOTE IS SCHEDULED FOR WEDNESDAY. AND AGAIN, THAT VOTE DOESN’T ACTUALLY DECIDE IF THEY’RE GOING TO CLOSE SCHOOLS OR NOT. IT JUST OPENS UP A THREE MONTH PUBLIC COMME
Advertisement
Pittsburgh Public Schools Board faces backlash amid proposed school closures
Hundreds of Pittsburgh Public Schools parents, students, and teachers packed the Pittsburgh School Board public hearing Monday with a unified message: slow down and don’t rush the vote to begin the process of potentially closing multiple school buildings.“Why are we rushing into a vote that could have such devastating consequences for the city?” parent Andy Kubis asked.The proposed closures stem from a feasibility study conducted by consulting group ERS.Many parents expressed frustration with the lack of detailed data in the plan. “The ERS plan is lacking in data, particularly when it comes to demographics, transportation costs, capital improvements, plans, and long-term costs. Considering the creation of this plan was driven by concerns about our budget deficits, you’d think we’d be looking at some financial estimates," parent Martha Riecks said. Adding to their concerns, ERS recommended that the district hire a demographer to provide a clearer picture of the impact of the closures — a step that has not yet been taken.The majority of families at the hearing represented three of the schools proposed for closure: Conroy, the Student Achievement Center, and Woolslair.Most speakers are opposed to closing schools altogether. However, a smaller group acknowledged the need.“I also believe it’s important for the district to close some of the facilities that are no longer needed because of declining enrollment in the aging population. It’s never going to be easy to choose to close schools. I believe it’s your job to figure out what to do, whether it’s the original ERS plan, the updated plan that was rolled out, or even this parent proposal," parent Mark Weaver said. School Board President Gene Walker addressed the crowd, “The work that we’ve been doing up to this point, a lot of it is really hard, and it certainly is not and has not been perfect,” Walker said. “We and I share many of the same concerns that many have expressed, and some will express tonight, but I believe this board is committed to ensuring that all information is provided.”The board will vote on Wednesday.
PITTSBURGH —
Hundreds of Pittsburgh Public Schools parents, students, and teachers packed the Pittsburgh School Board public hearing Monday with a unified message: slow down and don’t rush the vote to begin the process of potentially closing multiple school buildings.
“Why are we rushing into a vote that could have such devastating consequences for the city?” parent Andy Kubis asked.
Many parents expressed frustration with the lack of detailed data in the plan.
“The ERS plan is lacking in data, particularly when it comes to demographics, transportation costs, capital improvements, plans, and long-term costs. Considering the creation of this plan was driven by concerns about our budget deficits, you’d think we’d be looking at some financial estimates," parent Martha Riecks said.
Adding to their concerns, ERS recommended that the district hire a demographer to provide a clearer picture of the impact of the closures — a step that has not yet been taken.
The majority of families at the hearing represented three of the schools proposed for closure: Conroy, the Student Achievement Center, and Woolslair.
Most speakers are opposed to closing schools altogether. However, a smaller group acknowledged the need.
“I also believe it’s important for the district to close some of the facilities that are no longer needed because of declining enrollment in the aging population. It’s never going to be easy to choose to close schools. I believe it’s your job to figure out what to do, whether it’s the original ERS plan, the updated plan that was rolled out, or even this parent proposal," parent Mark Weaver said.
School Board President Gene Walker addressed the crowd, “The work that we’ve been doing up to this point, a lot of it is really hard, and it certainly is not and has not been perfect,” Walker said. “We and I share many of the same concerns that many have expressed, and some will express tonight, but I believe this board is committed to ensuring that all information is provided.”