Cops forced to watch video of teacher having sex with boy as bank records catch her out

WARNING, DISTRESSING CONTENT: Allison Havemann-Niedrach was charged with seven counts of sexual crimes against a 15-year-old middle school student she was 'obsessed' with, but she denies the charges

19:13, 01 Apr 2025Updated 19:14, 01 Apr 2025

The alleged victim was in her classes until her arrest(Image: Freehold Borough Police Department)

A teacher has allegedly been caught having sex with an underage student after bank records caught her out. Allison Havemann-Niedrach, 44, allegedly abused the 15-year-old student and sent him more than 25,000 texts.

Authorities were able to back up their evidence by catching the teacher out via her bank records, court documents claim. She has now been charged with seven counts of sexual crimes, but she denies all of the charges.

‌

Article continues below

The teacher was first probed by investigators at Freehold Intermediate School in New Jersey when the vice principal told police that he was worried about a relationship between her and the eighth-grader. A colleague had allegedly spotted Allison “rubbing the victim’s neck and back” and “flirting with him and noticed her touching his leg”, the New York Post reported.

Allison allegedly sent the boy over 25,000 texts(Image: LinkedIn)

Another said the student had lunch in her room every day, prosecutors added. The child’s mum heard from her daughter that her son had been sitting in the teacher’s car. The victim reportedly told his pals that they were even dating, but he told cops he was dating Allison’s daughter and the teacher had done nothing inappropriate.

‌

But authorities said texts on his phone proved otherwise. Police say they found 25,000 text exchanges on the alleged victim’s phone, with prosecutors believing the teacher had become “obsessed”. Cops also had to watch a video of the pair engaging in sexual conduct.

Days later the child’s mum brought him to the police station where he apparently admitted to having sex with Allison. The abuse reportedly started early last year and stopped in June when the teacher was arrested.

Allison allegedly starting abusing the boy early last year(Image: Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office)

‌

Authorities said it happened at Allison’s house and at hotels that she’d paid for, and the student was in her class until her arrest..

The teacher was charged on Tuesday with single counts of aggravated sexual assault, child endangerment through the manufacture of child sex abuse materials, official misconduct and sexual assault, as well as three counts of endangering.

She was bailed to her parent’s home after her initial arrest. Asia Michael, the district’s Superintendent of Schools, said: “The District takes each and every allegation of this nature very seriously and takes action swiftly when appropriate and as needed.

Article continues below

“Upon the advice of counsel, and in consideration that this matter is currently working through the criminal justice system, the District will not provide any comment.”

If you or somebody you know has been affected by this story, contact Victim Support for free, confidential advice on 08 08 16 89 111 or visit their website.

For the latest breaking news and stories from across the globe from the Daily Star, sign up for our newsletter by clicking here.